Most genuine movie lovers will more than likely agree that the single most common ingredient that transforms a good movie into a most memorable one is the screenplay. Of course, strong acting performances are also vital, but even the best of actors and actresses cannot overcome a bad or weak script. Conversely, an exceptional screenwriter can make the blandest of players sound far better than he or she deserves to sound.

I am one of those movie buffs who enjoy watching a picture multiple times, and the reason I do so (more often than not) is to savour a particular exchange of dialogue that has captured my imagination. So I have begun sorting through my favourite scenes down the decades, with the idea of placing outstanding monologues or conversations into a new segment on the blog. This will be the first (and hopefully not the last) of such segments. They will not be in any order of importance or chronology, just jotted down willy-nilly as I recall them. SPOILER ALERT: Many of the excerpts I have chosen will reveal pivotal plot factors, so if you do not want to have movies you have not yet watched spoiled, I respectfully suggest you cease reading at this point.

Movies that Inspired Star Wars: The Searchers - Featuring Bryan ...

THE SEARCHERS (1956) – Screenplay by Frank S. Nugent. Director John Ford.

Frank Nugent died from a heart attack at fifty-seven, thus robbing the cinema of his wonderful screen-writing talents far too early. In fact, he only had 21 feature films credited to his name, yet managed to win two awards from the Writers Guild of America (WGA) for Best Written Comedy. The first was for The Quiet Man (1952), the other for Mister Roberts (1955). He also penned two of John Ford’s famous ‘Cavalry Trilogy’ – Fort Apache (1948) and She Wore a Yellow Ribbon (1949). The WGA deemed his screenplay for The Searchers to be one of the 101 greatest screenplays of all time! A former film critic with the New York Times, he would preside over the WGA from 1957 until 1958. Back in his days as a film critic he made the following comment on the recently released The Wizard of Oz (1939): ‘It is all so well-intentioned, so genial and so gay, that any reviewer who would look down his nose at the fun-making should be spanked and sent off, supper-less, to bed.’

Harry Carey Jr., noted character actor, has passed away

Ethan tells Brad about Lucy’s fate

Setting the scene: Ethan Edwards (John Wayne), Martin Pawley (Jeffrey Hunter) and Brad Jorgensen (Harry Carey Jr) have been tracking a band of Comanche that raided Ethan’s brother Aaron’s ranch, killed both Aaron and his wife Martha, and abducted Ethan’s two nieces, teenaged Lucy (Pippa Scott) and little girl Debbie (Natalie Wood). A small part of the Comanche band had broken off from the main group and headed up a canyon. Ethan has just returned from following their tracks into the canyon. Lucy’s beau, Brad, has been watching the main body of Comanche and has spotted Lucy wearing her dress and cavorting in the camp and excitedly tells Ethan of what he has observed:

Ethan: ‘What you saw wasn’t Lucy.’

Brad: ‘But it was, I tell you!’

Ethan: ‘What you saw was a buck wearin’ Lucy’s dress. I found Lucy back in the canyon. Wrapped her in my coat, buried her with my own hands. I thought it best to keep it from ya.’

Brad: ‘Did they…? Was she…?’

Ethan: ‘What do you want me to do? Draw you a picture? Spell it out? Don’t ever ask me! Long as you live, don’t ever ask me more.’

NOTE: For all those fans who say that John Wayne could not act – I suggest you watch him in this scene (and, indeed, for the entire movie). He is superb. It is worth mentioning that Wayne nailed his speech recounting his discovery and burial of Lucy on the first take, but for some inexplicable reason the camera had stopped. A most irritated John Ford asked the operator what was wrong with the camera, but as the man began to answer, power to the camera suddenly returned and Wayne took another crack at it. It was later learned that there had been no mechanical or electrical malfunction at all. Supporting actor Ward Bond had been in need of a shave, so he had pulled the plug on the camera in order to use his electric razor! The crew never did tell Ford, for fear he would physically harm Bond.

martin pawley | samtertainment

Martin (Jeff Hunter) & Ethan on the trail of the Comanche band

Back to the story: After searching a year or more for Debbie and the Comanche band that had taken her, Ethan and Martin are compelled to turn back when the trail gets cold:

Martin: ‘Well, why don’t you say it? We’re beat, and you know it.’

Ethan: ‘Nope. Our turnin’ back don’t mean nothin’. Not in the long run. If she’s alive, she’s safe. For a while, they’ll keep her to raise as one of their own until…she’s of an age to…’

Martin: ‘Do you think maybe there’s a chance we still might find her?’

Ethan: ‘An Indian will chase a thing until he thinks he’s chased it enough. Then he quits. Same way when he runs. Seems like he never learns there’s such a thing as a critter who’ll just keep coming on. So we’ll find ‘em in the end I promise you. We’ll find ‘em. Just as sure as the…turnin’ of the Earth.’

Martin and Laurie | Jeffrey hunter, Classic movies, Musical movies

Laurie (Vera Miles) & Martin Pawley

NOTE: Ethan and Martin return to the Jorgensen ranch, set out a second time to find Debbie, then return just as Martin’s frustrated girlfriend Laurie Jorgensen (Vera Miles) is about to get married to someone else. Almost immediately, they learn of the Comanche band’s whereabouts and prepare to raid their camp and rescue Debbie.

Laurie: ‘You’re not goin’, not this time.’

Martin: ‘Are you crazy?’

Laurie: ‘It’s too late. She’s a woman grown now.’

Martin: ‘But I gotta go, Laurie. I gotta fetch her home.’

Laurie: ‘Fetch what home? The leavings a Comanche buck sold time and again to the highest bidder, with savage brats of her own?’

Martin: ‘Laurie, shut your mouth.’

Laurie: ‘Do you know what Ethan will do if he has a chance? He’ll put a bullet in her brain. I tell you, Martha would want him too.’

Martin: ‘Only if I’m dead.’


Final word: In this writer’s opinion, The Searchers is the best western ever made, directed by the best ever director of westerns, starring the best ever western star – and boasting the best ever western screenplay!


  1. Memorable lines for me. In Clementine, Earp (Henry Fonda) asks the barman and he responds, “Mac, have you ever been in love? No, I’ve been a bartender all my life.” Ann Sheridan as the sexy Nora Prentiss to the doctor (Kent Smith), “I may not have always been handled with care, but I’m not shopworn.” Nathan Brittles in Yellow Ribbon, “Never apologize. It’s a sign of weakness.”

    • Great lines, Craig. My favourite western lines are a brief six-word exchange between Viggo Mortensen and Ed Harris (in ‘Appaloosa’), after they were involved in a lightning fast gunfight with three other professionals:
      ‘That happened quick’, said Viggo. ‘Everybody could shoot’, was Ed’s laconic reply. Boy, would I love to be able to write dialogue like that!

  2. The Searchers is one of my all-time favorite movies (that happens to be a western). My other five favorite westerns are My Darling Clementine, Duel in the Sun, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon, Tombstone, and my all-time favorite movie (that I first saw in theatrical release in 1969), Peckinpah’s masterpiece, The Wild Bunch. Off hand, Duel in the Sun is the only western I can think of in which the woman is absolutely essential — without Pearl there is no movie.

    • Three of your top six made it into my top six also, Craig. I have never been a fan of Jennifer Jones so ‘Duel in the Sun’ missed out; I never much like it when film-makers drastically alter history in the name of entertainment, so ‘My Darling Clementine’ misses also (must be the historian in me, but you could drive a tank through the holes in that film). ‘The Wild Bunch’ just never grabbed me, but I am a huge fan of ‘The Searchers’, Tombstone’ and ‘She Wore a Yellow Ribbon’. I would include ‘Shane’ and ‘The Magnificent 7’ in my top six and, although it is more a comedy than a western, I love ‘Support Your Local Sheriff’ with Jim Garner. ‘The Searchers’ is in my top five films of ANY genre.

  3. The Searchers, is a great movie, it’s a great story told. Also the scenes are great, John Wayne framed in the door way is great, also at the end, not a dry eye in the house.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.