This was the first film produced by Marilyn Monroe’s own company. It made a slight profit even though it is as dull as dish water. Laurence Olivier was already contracted before her to play the lead, so she was stuck with him. And he with her. It was anything but a happy pairing. There were problems everywhere, most of them the fault of the gorgeous Marilyn. Indeed, she looks as lovely in this movie as in anything else she ever did, but by most accounts she was an abomination to work with.
Marilyn as gorgeous as ever
Olivier directed and, according to actress Jean Kent, his difficulties with his leading lady ‘caused him to age 15 years’. The normally placid photographer Jack Cardiff also struggled to get along with her. He recalled how Olivier often referred to her as a ‘bitch’. Co-star Richard Wattis had a lot of scenes with Marilyn and, again according to Miss Kent, he took to drinking ‘because takes had to be done so many times.’ Kent complained that MM was regularly late to arrive on the set and often ‘appeared dirty and disheveled.’ She never said a line the same way twice, seemed completely unable to hit her marks on the set, and would not make a move without first consulting her acting coach Paula Strasberg. When Olivier ordered Strasberg off the set at one point, Marilyn refused to continue until she was restored. The final straw came when an exasperated Olivier threw his hands in the air and ordered his leading lady to ‘try and be sexy’. She never forgave him. Donald Sinden bore mixed feelings for her. ‘Of course, as a sex symbol she was stunning’, he said, ‘but sadly, she must be one of the silliest women I have ever met.’
with Paula Strasberg, her acting coach
The other members of the cast of The Prince and the Showgirl may not have been aware that Marilyn was not well throughout the shoot. She was suffering from various illnesses that caused severe amounts of water retention and affected her dress size at different times. As a result four different sizes of her white gown had to be made available. She was also pregnant to husband Arthur Miller and did, in fact, suffer a miscarriage during the shoot. All these issues aside, however, the fact remains that this picture is a bore. It has no charm and there exists not a spark of chemistry between the two stars, nothing whatsoever that even faintly suggests they care for each other. In all, it has just one thing going for it, and that is the sheer beauty of its leading lady, for Marilyn looks as exquisitely attractive as she has ever looked on the screen. Her personality and girlish charm are all that make the picture watchable. As for Olivier, well, he is about as exciting as a dressage event, but nowhere near as appealing as the horses.
In 2011, Simon Curtis directed My Week with Marilyn, a feature that looked at the making of The Prince and the Showgirl, in particular her difficulties making the picture and her reliance on a young third director named Colin Clark for whom she developed an attachment. At times it is a very moving film, one that helps us understand how fragile Marilyn’s mind-set was, and how insecure she felt in the profession she had chosen for herself. The wonderful actress Michelle Williams is quite remarkable as Marilyn and thoroughly deserved her Oscar nomination. She, too, is a beautiful woman, but would probably be the first to admit that she could not hold a candle to the real Marilyn.
Michelle Williams as MM in
My Week With Marilyn (2011)
I suppose I feel about Marilyn Monroe the way most of her male fans do. Colin Clark would have us believe he, too, was captivated by her sweetness and vulnerability. He wanted to love her and to help her, but she was beyond salvation by him or anyone else. She was aboard the fame train, riding it to the end of the line, whatever the outcome. As far as Mr. Clark’s story goes, we have only his word for what occurred between him and Marilyn. And there must surely be doubts about that, for his own words cast them. After seeing her on the set for the first time he wrote the following description of the world’s number one love goddess: ‘Nasty complexion, a lot of facial hair, shapeless figure and, when the glasses came off, a very vague look in her eye. No wonder she is so insecure.’ These are scarcely the words of one who was apparently captivated by her beauty, if we are to take My Week with Marilyn at face value.
the real Colin Clark Eddie Redmayne as Colin in the movie
Unfortunately, there is no-one to verify any of Clark’s recollections regarding what happened when he and Marilyn were alone. All we have is the man’s diary. The sequence in which she takes too many pills, locks herself in her room, then asks for Clark to come see her, does not ring quite true to me. He says he climbed through her bedroom window, lay down beside the incoherent woman and proceeded to tell her he loved her. And that is all that happens – according to Clark. Marilyn later stated she could not recall anything from that night. She was too out of it. The worrying aspect of the story is his assertions that he felt compelled to protect and ‘save’ her. Somehow, recording details of their intimacy and Marilyn’s indiscretions (she was, after all, married at the time), then writing a book about it, does not strike me as being overly protective, especially since the lady under discussion was no longer alive to refute any of it.
Marilyn and Arthur Miller
Watching this film I cannot keep from thinking about her tragic life and death. Just a half a dozen years after making The Prince and the Showgirl she was no more. Still just as beautiful, but dead at 36. She never did find true happiness. After reading extensively about her, it seems to me that her entire life was one long search for the right man, yet her desire for fame and recognition as an actress of note more or less insured she only ever met the wrong ones. She used them as a comforting shoulder to lean on for temporary security, and if that sometimes involved sex, well, so be it. Marilyn wanted love and security. Her men wanted her physically. Clark, in my opinion, was just another in a long line who professed a desire to help her, but ultimately exploited her. In the end she had even less idea of how to achieve those goals than when she started.
For actresses in Hollywood, after beauty what’s number 2? Talent? Luck? Sexual favors? Remember Garson Kanin’s comment about great beauties not needing to be great actresses because they don’t need to be. Monroe didn’t have to work very hard. (I believe that Kanin, when making his comment, was thinking of Vivien Leigh as a counterexample.)
There are always exceptions to the rule, Craig, and I think your choice of Vivien Leigh as such an exception is an accurate one. As far as Marilyn is concerned, I have never been of that opinion (held by many) that she was a very good actress. I think she was lovely to look at and possessed a personality that was seldom uninteresting. Regarding beauty AND talent, I believe that Grace Kelly was just starting to spread her acting wings when she ceased her career.
I don’t get how she could kiss and flirt whilst married and pregnant..she should be over the moon! Not looking for a man!
A lot of people have made a lot of excuses for MM’s behaviour. One wonders if she would have gained as much sympathy and understanding after her death had she looked like Phyllis Diller instead of like Marilyn Monroe.